Board of Library Trustees Meeting
March 7, 2006

7:05 p.m.


Medway Public Library


Attendees:

Trustees:

MaryAnn Cabibbo, Vice Chairman
David Cole
Patrick Marshall, Director
William Roberts, Secretary
Wendy Rowe, Chairman

Minutes

  1. Approval of Mar 7, 2006 agenda

  2. Motion to approve agenda: DC1, WLR2. Passed unanimously

  3. Secretary’s report

  4. Motion to approve Jan 3 minutes: MAC1, WLR2, passed unanimously

  5. Citizens Speak

  6. None present

  7. Budget Report

  8. Director’s Report

  9. Minuteman Notes:

    Prepared a fact sheet to help educate town officials during the budgeting process.

  10. Old business

    1. Director’s Review

      Chairman thanked those that had prepared their evaluations and lambasted those who hadn't. These need to be done forthwith. Actual review will take place next month.

  11. New Business

    1. Walter’s retirement – What to do.

    2. Walter is retiring March 31. He will stage a return performance for the next Players show.

      He's shared with town hall. From the library's point of view his is a 30hr position. We need to keep this as the building really requires 30hrs of maintenance and more a week.

      His daughter Michelle has been doing some cleaning. She can do more and her friend John, whom Walter recommends can be used as a temp.

      Motion. Keep the 30hr maintenance position and employ Michelle and John as temps until it's filled. (MAC1, DC2) passed unanimously

    3. Annual town report submission – Due to town hall prior to 3/17

    4. Legislative day

    5. April 5. Chance to meet legislators and lobby for library funding.

    6. Long Range planning – committee and how -to.

    7. We need to do this. Metrowest will help. Starting with a clean slate since last time the Library was preparing for the building project and that was the focus of the plan.

      Need to do a survey. Possibly using survey professionals. There was some concern that citizens might feel we were blowing away their money.

      Need to form a committee comprised of some trustees, a couple staff, and some friends. Various focus groups would be interviewed: trustees, staff, friends, town officials, the great unwashed...

      Bill, Wendy and MaryAnn volunteered to be on the committee.

    8. FY 07 budget review. (3 different budgets enclosed)

      Patrick presented 3 budget proposals:

      1. Full Funding
        • Would be as if we'd never laid off anybody
        • Would have to give laid off employees chance to get their jobs back
        • Expenses would be back as well

        Under the general "hope springs eternal" category, Patrick notified the Town Administrator that above and beyond the full funding budget, the Library would need 2 additional part time library assistants to actually remain open the same hours as before. The form making the request is included here

      2. Reduced with gradual restoration
        • Gradually gets us back to meeting certification requirements
        • By FY09 essentially at full funding levels except for staffing
        • Restores some positions slowly

      3. Reduced Funding
        • continue to languish hopelessly in the pit

      Motion: Trustees approve budget proposals as submitted by Director. DC1, MAC2. Passed unanimously

  12. Other

  13. Next Meeting Apr 4, 2006

  14. Adjournment 8:20

    Motion to adjourn: MAC1, DC2. Passed unanimously


(Jan/Feb 05 activity)




January and February have been busy times here at the library. FY 07 budget planning has hit full force with the Town Administrator looking for not only for next year budget submissions but also forecasts through FY 09. I have submitted three scenarios all level service funded. The first one has the library at its current level and, though given slight increases, we would be below the municipal appropriation requirement the entire duration. Second option shows the library again at current levels but regaining certification status by FY 09. The last budget submitted showed the library at level services before the 22% cut of this year. The Town Administrator was made aware that the Board of Trustees had not yet approved any budgets and has stated that she is using these as guidelines only.


I have been asked to participate on the NELA Conference Planning Committee. The conference will take place in Burlington, VT in mid October. The commitment is 4 meetings to be held in Wellesley, Burlington, VT, Wilton, NH and Worcester plus the four days for the actual convention. The remainder of the work is done via e-mail and on one’s own.


We have scattered three chairs in the nonfiction area of the library. They seem to be proving a popular addition to the furnishings. These were chairs that were in storage downstairs. I am looking into rearranging some other items such as reference and study tables but will wait until summer.


I have also begun discussions to bring Wireless access to the library. Directors from Millis and Medfield expressed an interest in working with us so that perhaps we could get discounts or deals on costs to have buildings surveyed. I’m hoping that I can share their expertise, as I am not familiar with wireless technology.


Circulation continues to be down from this time last year. We are currently circulating 10,000 items less. People counters are showing an average of 350 people a day using the library. I do not have figures to compare as we just installed the counters this fall.



Respectfully submitted,


Patrick W Marshall


Report of the Medway Public Library 2005



In 1994, Isaac Asimov wrote, “I received the fundamentals of my education in school, but that was not enough. My real education, the superstructure, the details, the true architecture, I got out of the public library. For an impoverished child whose family could not afford to buy books, the library was the open door to wonder and achievement, and I can never be sufficiently grateful that I had the wit to charge through that door and make the most of it. Now, when I read constantly about the way in which library funds are being cut and cut, I can only think that the door is closing and that American society has found one more way to destroy itself.”

This past year, “the door” of the Medway Public Library has closed a great deal. Drastic budget cuts have resulted in a loss of staffing, service hours, programs and resources. These reductions totaled 22% of the library budget and are stretching remaining staff and resources to their limits.

Staffing changes caused by the budget reduction were most difficult for the library to handle. Muriel Bulman retired after 17 years of dedicated library service. Her position was eliminated. Sandra Faist, a seven year employee, and Renee Hake, who served for four years, were each laid off. The loss of these positions resulted in the library closing its doors entirely on weekends as well as Monday and Wednesday evenings. In all, staff time has been cut 63 hours and the number of people working at the library has been reduced to levels not seen since the late 1980s.

When compared with 2004, the library is open fifteen hours less per week. These reduced hours not only make it difficult for students and other patrons to get the materials they need, but also impacts the many groups using the library’s meeting rooms since there are no longer enough open hours to host popular evening meetings.

In the fall, the library, in order to maintain State Certification, had to apply for a waiver from the State. The Massachusetts Board of Library Commissioners granted the waiver allowing Medway residents the continued opportunity to borrow materials from other Massachusetts libraries. The library is also able to receive over $18,000 in State grant funds and maintains its eligibility to apply for other federal and state grants.

Despite these cutbacks, business at the library continues to be strong though reduced from prior years. In all, nearly 154,000 items were borrowed from the library. This includes all DVD’s, books, audio and magazines. The meeting rooms were booked 322 times last year by such groups as girl scouts, Medway Players, Medway Community Education and Friends of Choate Park. Computers also continued to show their popularity with Internet terminals booked more than 120 times per week. All of this business shows that residents continue to view the library as a vital part of the community.

Children’s services make up nearly half of the total library business. In 2005, 1900 children participated in 122 programs held at the library. 250 children took part in the summer reading program. Programs held included Pre-school Powerhouse, Books and Cooks, American Girl Tea Time and Wee Ones Lapsit.

The Friends of Medway Library continue to provide much needed support to the library, supplementing many of the programs and services. The Friends provided funding for all children’s programs, many books, audios, DVD’s and music CD’s. Museum passes also continued to be funded by this group including Roger Williams Park Zoo, Boston Children’s Museum and Museum of Science. These services would have been cut this year had not the Friends of Medway Library funded them. We continue to thank them for their immense support.

A large and loyal group of volunteers assist the library staff on a daily basis. These hard working people finish the tasks that library staff are unable to get to including shelving of materials and making copies. Volunteers include members of the senior tax relief program, Medway High and King Philip students and members of the Medway community. Combined, they put in well over a thousand hours a year of service every day that the library is open. We thank them deeply for all they do.

Finally, the library staff deserves a large thank you for their hard work and dedication. Despite the persistent funding issues faced by the Town and library, each and every one of them gives their all to bring the highest quality service to the people of Medway. They continue to strive to make Medway Public Library the educational, recreational and cultural center it truly is for the community.

Please visit the library to browse the collection, use the computers, do research or just relax. Our website address is www.medwaylib.org and many of our services, including placing holds, database access and much more, are available from home via the web. Your comments and suggestions are always appreciated. Share them with library staff or by emailing the library director at mwdir@minlib.net.

Respectfully submitted,

Patrick W Marshall – Library Director

Wendy E Rowe – Chair, Medway Public Library Board of Trustees






Budget Report
Medway Public Library
1-Mar-06
Account Acct # Start Balance Expen. to date End Balance % Spent
Longevity 5150 $500.00 $200.00 $300.00 40.00%
Salaries Full Time 5110 $156,744.00 $86,002.37 $70,741.63 54.87%
Salaries Part Time 5111 $83,545.00 $78,464.97 $5,080.03 93.92%
Electricity 5211 $14,600.00 $10,294.22 $4,305.78 70.51%
Heating Fuel 5212 $8,000.00 $5,681.87 $2,318.13 71.02%
Water & Sewer 5231 $350.00 $166.09 $183.91 47.45%
Trash 5232 $1,200.00 $1,765.18 $(565.18) 147.10%
R &M Miscellaneous 5240 $7,000.00 $4,408.29 $2,591.71 62.98%
Telephone 5341 $1,850.00 $1,253.72 $596.28 67.77%
Postage 5343 $450.00 $444.00 $6.00 98.67%
Other Purchased Services 5380 $1,500.00 $1,605.90 $(105.90) 107.06%
Supplies 5400 $3,500.00 $1,637.08 $1,862.92 46.77%
Books /Periodicals 5521 $3,137.00 $2,403.37 $733.63 76.61%
Media Materials 5427 $1,000.00 $601.07 $398.93 60.11%
Dues, Subscriptions, Meetings 5730 $500.00 $117.50 $382.50 23.50%
In State Travel 5710 $850.00 $348.72 $501.28 41.03%

TOTAL $284,726.00 $195,394.35 $89,331.65 68.63%








Start Balance Expen. To date Income to date Account Bal
Revolving Fund 4773 $28,968.44 $22,500.00 $12,986.47 $19,454.91






Memorial Donations 6011 $3,949.10 $4,446.75 $1,883.00 $1,385.35






Free Public Library 2017 $52,730.48 $32,863.09 $30,741.67 $50,609.06






Tuchinsky Fund



$-

Full Funding Budget (Level service)

Overview

Pg_ 1_Department Cover
pg_ 2 Personnel Detail
Pg_ 3_Expense Detail


Sheet 1: Pg_ 1_Department Cover

FY 2007 DEPARTMENT BUDGET COVER SHEET




Full Funding Budget (Level service)












Department Name: Library




Department No: 610














Statement of Programs/Responsibilities/Goals/Legal Mandates








Mission Statement : To disseminate knowledge, to bring the breadth of human culture into the community and to promote the love of reading.






















Actual Actual Requested* Budget YTD 1/31/06 Request** Forecast Forecast


FY' 04 FY' 05 FY' 06 FY' 06 FY' 06 FY' 07 FY' 08 FY' 09
Salaries:
$266,300 $272,696 $288,331 $240,789 $142,308 $297,983 $298,399 $299,721
Expenses:
$98,312 $93,847 $116,450 $43,937 $26,217 $112,300 $117,900 $124,450
Total Dept Budget:
$364,612 $366,543 $404,781 $284,726 $168,525 $410,283 $416,299 $424,171










Employees (Individuals not positions/slots/FTE's)


















Full-Time:
3 3 3 3
3 3 3










Part-Time
8 8 8 5
8 8 8










On Call Inspectors


















FTE's (Full-time equivalents)


















Total:





















* FY'05 level service budget requested for FY'06 prior to $2.7 million cut







** Level service budget compared to FY'06





Sheet 2: pg_ 2 Personnel Detail

FY 2007 DEPARTMENT BUDGET PERSONNEL DETAIL





Full Level service funding


















Department Name: Library 610







Department Code: Salaries/ Longevity





























Job Title Grade/Step July 1, 2006 Pay Rate Hours/ wk Actual FY' 04 Actual FY' 05 Request* FY' 06 Budget FY' 06 YTD 1/31/06 FY' 06 Request** FY' 07 Forecast FY' 08 Forecast FY' 09
1 Director
Salary
$59,360 $56,500 $58,500 $56,106
$58,269 $57,789 $57,789
2 Children's Lib 8/4 $22.89 35 $40,531 $40,731 $37,838 $37,838
$41,714 $41,860 $42,882
3 Tech Services 5/5 $19.14 35 $31,476 $31,904 $34,016 $34,016
$35,080 $35,217 $35,217
4 Circulation 5/5 $19.14 32 $27,056 $28,687 $30,917 $28,985
$31,891 $32,015 $32,015
5 Outreach 5/5 $19.14 21 $18,886 $19,022 $20,289 $20,289
$20,928 $21,010 $21,210
6 Lib Asst 3/5 $16.42 24 $18,726 $18,857 $20,193 $3,156
$20,817 $20,892 $20,992
7 Lib Asst 3/5 $16.42 20 $14,086 $15,334 $16,578 $16,578
$17,098 $17,160 $17,160
8 Lib Asst 3/5 $16.42 20 $11,179 $11,697 $16,578 $2,869
$17,098 $17,160 $17,160
9 Lib Asst 3/5 $16.42 14 $10,807 $10,883 $11,604 $9,947
$11,968 $12,012 $12,012
10 Lib Asst 3/5 $16.42 15 $11,579 $11,606 $12,433 $1,722
$12,823 $12,870 $12,870
11 Maintenance 5/5 $19.14 30 $27,280 $27,475 $29,385 $29,385
$30,297 $30,414 $30,414

Total


$270,966 $272,696 $288,331 $240,891 $142,308 $297,983 $298,399 $299,721
































* FY'05 level service budget requested for FY'06 prior to $2.7 million cut










** Level service budget compared to FY'06

































































































































































































































Sheet 3: Pg_ 3_Expense Detail

FY 2007 DEPARTMENT BUDGET EXPENSE DETAIL





Full Level Service Funding



Department Name: Library





Department Code: 610 Expenses















Acct No Account Name Actual FY' 04 Actual FY' 05 Request* FY' 06 Budget FY' 06 YTD 1/31/06 FY' 06 Request** FY' 07 Forecast FY' 08 Forecast FY' 09 Explanation/Calculations/Other Information
5211 Electricity $13,721 $14,025 $14,500 $14,600 $9,216 $19,000 $19,300 $19,300 based on DOE Forcast and a 2% increase
5212 Heating Fuel $7,041 $7,821 $8,500 $8,000 $4,056 $10,000 $10,200 $10,400 based on DOE Forcast and a 2% increase
5231 Water/ Sewer $503 $604 $600 $350 $184 $400 $450 $450 Plan on 2% increase during period
5232 Trash $1,287 $1,179 $1,300 $1,200 $1,765 $2,000 $2,000 $2,100 Plan on 2% increase during period
5240 Repair/ Maintenance $6,108 $5,872 $7,000 $7,000 $3,424 $8,000 $8,000 $9,000 Much has been covered by state aid in past
5341 Phone $1,749 $1,862 $1,700 $1,850 $1,097 $1,900 $1,900 $1,900 No increase
5343 Postage $888 $444 $900 $450 $444 $500 $550 $550 Postage expected to rise again
5380 Other Purch Serv $3,102 $3,088 $5,600 $1,500 $1,358 $3,000 $3,000 $3,000 Return to past levels
5400 Supplies $6,050 $5,679 $7,500 $3,500 $1,220 $6,000 $6,000 $6,000 Return to past levels
5427 Media/ audio Materials $10,730 $10,304 $12,000 $1,000 $601 $10,000 $15,000 $15,000 Material purchases must = 16% of budget
5521 Books/ Periodicals $45,582 $47,260 $55,000 $3,137 $2,403 $50,000 $50,000 $55,000 to qualify for State Certification
5710 Instate Travel $532 $1,024 $750 $850 $349 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 Remaining at current levels
5730 Dues/ subs/ meets $1,020 $847 $1,100 $500 $118 $500 $500 $750 Contract calls for stipend if 3 wkshps attend

































Total: $98,313 $100,009 $116,450 $43,937 $26,235 $112,300 $117,900 $124,450














* FY'05 level service budget requested for FY'06 prior to $2.7 million cut








** Level service budget compared to FY'06






Reduced/Current Funding Budget (Level service)

Overview

Pg_ 1_Department Cover
pg_ 2 Personnel Detail
Pg_ 3_Expense Detail



Sheet 1: Pg_ 1_Department Cover

FY 2007 DEPARTMENT BUDGET COVER SHEET




Reduced/Current Funding Budget (Level service)











Department Name: Library




Department No: 610














Statement of Programs/Responsibilities/Goals/Legal Mandates








Mission Statement : To disseminate knowledge, to bring the breadth of human culture into the community and to promote the love of reading.






















Actual Actual Requested* Budget YTD 1/31/06 Request** Forecast Forecast


FY' 04 FY' 05 FY' 06 FY' 06 FY' 06 FY' 07 FY' 08 FY' 09
Salaries:
$266,300 $272,696 $288,331 $240,789 $142,308 $243,323 $243,660 $244,882
Expenses:
$98,312 $93,847 $116,450 $43,937 $26,217 $49,700 $73,300 $94,900
Total Dept Budget:
$364,612 $366,543 $404,781 $284,726 $168,525 $293,023 $316,960 $339,782










Employees (Individuals not positions/slots/FTE's)


















Full-Time:
3 3 3 3
3 3 3










Part-Time
8 8 8 5
5 5 5










On Call Inspectors


















FTE's (Full-time equivalents)


















Total:





















* FY'05 level service budget requested for FY'06 prior to $2.7 million cut







** Level service budget compared to FY'06





Sheet 2: pg_ 2 Personnel Detail

FY 2007 DEPARTMENT BUDGET PERSONNEL DETAIL





Reduced / Current Level service funding


















Department Name: Library 610







Department Code: Salaries/ Longevity





























Job Title Grade/Step July 1, 2006 Pay Rate Hours/ wk Actual FY' 04 Actual FY' 05 Request* FY' 06 Budget FY' 06 YTD 1/31/06 FY' 06 Request** FY' 07 Forecast FY' 08 Forecast FY' 09
1 Director
Salary
$59,360 $56,500 $58,500 $56,106
$58,149 $57,789 $57,789
2 Children's Lib 8/4 $22.89 35 $40,531 $40,731 $37,838 $37,838
$41,714 $41,860 $42,882
3 Tech Services 5/5 $19.14 35 $31,476 $31,904 $34,016 $34,016
$35,080 $35,217 $35,217
4 Circulation 5/5 $19.14 30 $27,056 $28,687 $30,917 $28,985
$29,897 $30,014 $30,014
5 Outreach 5/5 $19.14 21 $18,886 $19,022 $20,289 $20,289
$20,928 $21,010 $21,210
6 Lib Asst 3/5 $16.42 0 $18,726 $18,857 $20,193 $3,156
$0 $0 $0
7 Lib Asst 3/5 $16.42 20 $14,086 $15,334 $16,578 $16,578
$17,098 $17,160 $17,160
8 Lib Asst 3/5 $16.42 0 $11,179 $11,697 $16,578 $2,869
$0 $0 $0
9 Lib Asst 3/5 $16.42 12 $10,807 $10,883 $11,604 $9,947
$10,259 $10,296 $10,296
10 Lib Asst 3/5 $16.42 0 $11,579 $11,606 $12,433 $1,722
$0 $0 $0
11 Maintenance 5/5 $19.14 30 $27,280 $27,475 $29,385 $29,385
$30,297 $30,314 $30,314

Total


$270,966 $272,696 $288,331 $240,891 $142,308 $243,422 $243,660 $244,882
































* FY'05 level service budget requested for FY'06 prior to $2.7 million cut










** Level service budget compared to FY'06